02.07.25

The life you save (for): Experiences dominate goods in motivating savings

Insights Report
Research Dialogue

Many people struggle to save for the future. Reframing the purpose of saving can help increase the motivation to save.

Summary

Because savings goals necessarily relate to future consumption, consumers face uncertainty about the degree to which a given savings goal target will be desirable at the time the goal is reached. As a result, goals that are seen as more versatile—satisfying a wider range of future preferences—are more likely to motivate savings than those that are less versatile. Building on this intuition, this study investigates how different types of savings goals motivate consumers to save.

Key Insights

  • Consumers are more motivated to initiate, invest in and complete savings goals that are framed in terms of experiences as opposed to material goods.
  • The motivational effect attenuates with very short goal-pursuit periods with less uncertainty involved and is stronger with long goal-pursuit periods.
  • Framing saving for retirement as experiential (e.g., saving for life after retirement) rather than material (e.g., saving for housing, insurance and maintenance) may enhance goal versatility and increase consumers’ motivation to save for the future.

Framing how a savings goal may meet future needs and preferences could increase the likelihood of all phases of saving—goal initiation, commitment and persistence.

Methodology

The researchers base their conclusions on one field study (N = 93,577), one field dataset evaluating real saving behavior over an 18-month period (N = 38,503), and six preregistered experiments (N = 5,813) across multiple saving contexts.

yin_jan2025_table1

Grant E. Donnelly

Ohio State University

Cait Lamberton

University of Pennsylvania

Michael I. Norton

Harvard University

Siyuan Yin

University of Pennsylvania 

Sign up for the TIAA Institute newsletter

Get the latest research and insights straight in your inbox

We are sorry.

The service that receives your request is unavailable at the moment. Please try again.